advice on controllers

Good evening to all, I apologize for my bad English
I haven t played swos since more than 25 years, so I can t do well in dribling and doing tricks. but I have to tell you that I am not with my current controller, joypad for xbox one.
so I decided to change.
I have the possibility to take an arcade stick (dead or alive) for 40 €, but I am not so convinced ... I also managed to find a Gravis PC Gamepad from the United States for 45 € ..... what do you think ? I felt this last in many discussions, is it so?
I await yours. thank you in advance.

do you think that compared to the xbox one joypad I take a step forward? I found various versions of gravis. some made in canada and others made in china ... are there differences between the two?
Also what do you think about this: ARCADE STICK DOA for xbox 360? ... better gravis? .... I don t remember my arcade sticks of the past ... I have total darkness.

yes that s for sure. ;D ;D ;D ;D
but what I ask you: compared to the xbox one controller, will I find improvements in the game? with xbox one controller I don t have great mastery and aim.
thanks for the answers.

last thing if i take gravis what adapter do i need? .. i saw that gravis has a black connector.

I found a tac-2, white color. made in usa. at the flea market, for € 7. Is this good to play sensible soccer? Is the price good? how is this joistick?